16% off the monthly demand charge, from a few hours of held load
Peak and power-factor management for an energy-intensive plant, measured on a full year of real 15-minute metering from a steel mill.
Executive summary
Holding the top 1% of 15-minute intervals cuts a steel plant’s billed monthly peak by 16% while moving 0.27% of its energy, measured on a full year of real metering.
Situation
The monthly demand charge is set by a few coincident spikes, and the plant runs below a 0.90 power factor for much of its running time.
Approach
A demand monitor and cap per month, and reactive compensation sized from 35,040 real 15-minute intervals.
Result
16% off the billed peak for 7.5 hours of held load a month; intervals below 0.90 power factor from 55% to 1%.
The problem
An electric-arc or rolling plant pays a monthly demand charge on its highest interval of the month, often on kVA, so a poor power factor raises it further. Published work on steel plants shows that moving energy-heavy steps out of peak intervals and correcting power factor cut the charge noticeably without lowering output.
I built a monitor that watches interval metering against a monthly demand target and holds deferrable load for a few hours a month, and measured the saving on a real plant’s metering.
- Team
- Plant manager, electrical and maintenance engineers, production scheduling, energy procurement
- Scale
- 960 MWh a year, 15-minute interval metering
- Systems
- SCADA and power-quality meters, the retailer’s interval data, MES or production scheduling
- Measure
- Billed monthly peak kW; intervals below 0.90 power factor; energy moved
What I built
A demand monitor that reads the interval meter every few minutes, projects the current 15-minute block and alerts the shift when it is heading above the month’s cap, with a short list of loads that can be deferred: furnace charging, compressor staging, a cooling or extraction cycle. Alongside it, a power-factor analysis sizes the reactive compensation needed for the plant’s real load pattern.
Results
I worked with a full year of real 15-minute metering from a steel plant: 35,040 intervals, 960 MWh, with active and reactive energy, power factor and the plant’s load-period classification. The monthly peak sat on average 50% above the month’s 95th percentile interval, so it was set by short coincident spikes rather than by sustained production.
| Cap on 15-minute demand | Billed peak removed | Energy moved to other intervals | Time held each month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month’s 99th percentile | 16% | 0.27% | 7.5 hours |
| Month’s 98th percentile | 21% | 0.70% | 15.0 hours |
That cap is reached in a median of 7.5 hours a month, a small enough window for the shift to defer a listed load each time. At the 98th percentile the cut grows to 21% for 15 hours of held demand a month.
Power factor
55% of the intervals in which the plant drew power ran below a 0.90 lagging power factor, carrying 41% of its energy. The problem sits mostly in light-load periods, when motors and transformers idle. An automatic capacitor bank sized to the 95th percentile of the reactive need, about 81 kvar, brings that share down to 1.1% and lifts the year’s average power factor from 0.90 to 0.99.
Data and method
- Data
- Steel Industry Energy Consumption, UCI Machine Learning Repository: 15-minute metering from DAEWOO Steel in Gwangyang, South Korea, 2018-01-01 to 2018-12-31, with energy, lagging and leading reactive energy, power factors, CO2 and load-period type.
- Peak cap
- Each month’s 99th and 98th percentile 15-minute demand; energy above the cap counted as moved to later intervals
- Power factor
- Reactive need to reach 0.95 in each interval; an automatic bank sized at the 95th percentile of that need
- Forecast
- Gradient-boosted regression on day of week, month and lagged daily energy; fitted January to September, tested October to December
- Measures
- Billed peak removed, energy moved, hours held, intervals below 0.90
Limitations
- One year from one plant. Tariff rules differ by network and retailer, so the saving in dollars is calculated with the plant’s own tariff.
- Moved energy assumes the deferred load can run later in the day without affecting output; production signs off the list of deferrable loads.
- The capacitor sizing is a first estimate from interval data; a power-quality survey confirms harmonics before a bank is specified.
- The plant’s output data is not in the dataset, so energy per tonne is not measured here.
How I would take it live
- Pull twelve months of interval data from the retailer or the plant meter, with the current network tariff
- Agree the list of deferrable loads and the monthly cap with production and maintenance
- Run the projection and alerts on the SCADA historian for a month in advisory mode
- Commission reactive compensation from a power-quality survey, then review peak, power factor and moved energy monthly