Manaz Afzal
Energy & Utilities · Commercial buildings

The audit budget pointed at the buildings that will be fined next year

Emissions-penalty exposure for a commercial building portfolio, tested on 23,162 real buildings’ benchmarking reports against ranking by ENERGY STAR score.

88%of next year’s penalties in the top 10% by forecast
63%ranking by ENERGY STAR score
33%of fined buildings were under the limit a year earlier
55%of those flagged in advance

Executive summary

Ranking buildings by forecast penalty exposure puts 88% of next year’s emissions penalties in the top 10% of a portfolio, against 63% for ranking by ENERGY STAR score.

88%of next year’s penalties in the top 10% by forecast
63%ranking by ENERGY STAR score
55%of newly fined buildings flagged a year ahead

Situation

Audit and retrofit budgets are ranked by ENERGY STAR score or energy intensity, neither of which measures the emissions fine.

Approach

Exposure computed from benchmarking reports with the law’s coefficients and limits, and next year’s penalty forecast, tested on 23,162 buildings.

Result

88% of next year’s penalties in the first 10% audited against 63%; 55% of buildings newly over the limit flagged in advance.

The problem

New York’s Local Law 97 fines large buildings for every tonne of carbon above a limit set for their use, from 2024. Owners and asset managers with portfolios rank buildings for audits and retrofits, and consultants advise starting with projected fines and the gap to the limit. Many portfolios still rank by ENERGY STAR score or energy use per square foot, neither of which measures the fine.

I wanted to know how much of next year’s penalties a portfolio reaches by auditing the buildings its usual ranking puts first, against ranking on computed exposure and a forecast of next year’s exposure.

Team
Head of facilities, asset managers, sustainability lead
Scale
Portfolios of tens to thousands of buildings over 25,000 square feet
Systems
ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager, utility bill data, CAFM or Yardi, capital planning
Measure
Next year’s penalty dollars reached per audit; buildings newly over the limit found in advance

What I built

An exposure model that turns each building’s annual benchmarking report into emissions using the coefficients in the law, compares them with the limit for its use, and forecasts next year’s penalty from the fuel mix, intensity, age and trend. The capital plan is ranked by forecast dollars at risk, and buildings close to the limit are flagged before they cross it.

Benchmarking reportElectricity, gas, oil,steam, floor areaExposureEmissions againstthe use-type limitForecastNext year’s penaltyat current trendCapital planAudits ranked bydollars at risk
The model runs on each year’s reports, so the plan updates as buildings change fuel or use.

Results

I worked with real benchmarking reports filed under New York City’s Local Law 84: 107,161 reports for calendar years 2022 to 2025 from buildings in the main use types, with emissions computed from metered fuel use and compared with the 2024 to 2029 limits. In calendar year 2025, 11% of buildings were over their limit, carrying US$346 million in penalties at US$268 a tonne.

I ranked 23,162 buildings on their 2024 reports and measured the penalties they incurred in 2025.

0%25%50%75%100%0%5%10%20%30%Forecast next-year exposureCurrent-year penalty exposureHighest energy use intensityLowest ENERGY STAR scoreRandom orderShare of the portfolio audited, in ranking order
Auditing the top 10% by forecast exposure reaches 88% of the next year’s penalty dollars. The same share ranked by lowest ENERGY STAR score reaches 63%. Data: NYC Open Data, Energy and Water Data Disclosure for Local Law 84
Ranking methodTop 5%Top 10%Top 20%Top 30%
Lowest ENERGY STAR score52%63%69%79%
Highest energy use intensity74%86%90%92%
Current-year penalty exposure83%88%91%93%
Forecast next-year exposure80%88%92%96%

Buildings that cross the limit next year

33% of the buildings over the limit in 2025 had been under it in 2024, so a list built from this year’s fines misses a third of next year’s. The forecast puts 55% of those newly exposed buildings in its top fifth, early enough to fund a fix before the first penalty.

Manufacturing/Industrial PlantUS$14.3m across 300 buildings21%Non-Refrigerated WarehouseUS$2.4m across 416 buildings14%Multifamily HousingUS$237.3m across 19,841 buildings11%HotelUS$4.2m across 705 buildings10%OfficeUS$23.5m across 2,220 buildings5%K-12 SchoolUS$3.5m across 1,877 buildings4%
Buildings burning fuel oil were over the limit 19% of the time, against 9% for buildings on gas and electricity alone; fuel switching is often the first measure.

Data and method

Data
NYC Open Data, Energy and Water Data Disclosure for Local Law 84 (calendar years 2022 to 2025): metered electricity, natural gas, fuel oil and district steam, floor area, use type, year built and ENERGY STAR score. Buildings under 25,000 square feet and implausible reports removed. Buildings are not named here.
Emissions
Local Law 97 coefficients for 2024 to 2029: electricity 0.000288962 tCO2e per kWh, natural gas 0.00005311, #2 oil 0.00007421 and district steam 0.00004493 tCO2e per kBtu
Limits
The 2024 to 2029 occupancy-group limits, mapped from each building’s primary use type; mixed-use buildings take the limit of their primary use, which approximates the city’s method
Forecast
Gradient-boosted regression of next year’s penalty on this year’s exposure, intensity, fuel mix, age, size and use type; fitted on 2023 to 2024 and tested on 2024 to 2025
Measures
Share of next year’s penalty dollars reached by the first 5% to 30% of buildings ranked

Limitations

How I would take it live

Financial impact

Retrofit money pointed at the fines

The gain is the penalty exposure an audit programme reaches first. The portfolio’s annual exposure is an assumption; the capture rates are measured.

InputValueSource
Portfolio penalty exposure a yearA$2,000,000
Reached by auditing the top 10%, forecast ranking88%Measured
Reached by ENERGY STAR ranking63%Measured

Calculation

  1. Exposure reached by the forecast rankingA$1,758,862
  2. Exposure reached by ENERGY STAR rankingA$1,252,082

A$506,780 more exposure in the first audit round

Measures still have to pay back; the ranking decides where the audits start.

Implementation and rollout

Four weeks from reports to a ranked capital plan

  1. Week 1

    Reports

    Three years of Portfolio Manager reports and utility bills.

    Asset managers, Manaz

  2. Week 2

    Exposure

    Emissions and limits computed for current and next periods.

    Sustainability lead, Manaz

  3. Week 3

    Forecast and rank

    Next-year exposure forecast; near-limit buildings flagged.

    Manaz

  4. Week 4

    Capital plan

    Audits scheduled by dollars at risk.

    Head of facilities

Tools

ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager, Utility bill data, Yardi or CAFM, Python, scikit-learn

Team

  • Head of facilities owns the capital plan
  • Asset managers building data
  • Sustainability lead compliance and reporting
  • Manaz exposure model and annual refresh

The timeline is a plan for a typical engagement; it depends on data access and how many systems are involved.

Risks and mitigations

What could go wrong in production, and the control for each

RiskMitigation
Mixed-use buildingsLimits computed per space when the floor breakdown is available.
Estimated readingsImplausible reports checked before ranking.
Rule changesCoefficients and limits updated each period.
Over-reliance on rankingAudits decide the measures.

Key takeaways

Key takeaways

  • ENERGY STAR score is a weak proxy for the fine.
  • Exposure ranking reaches 88% of next year’s penalties in the first tenth.
  • A third of next year’s fines come from buildings under the limit today.
  • Fuel oil buildings are the first fuel-switch candidates.