Fuel for a trades fleet: the station matters, the day barely does
A year of NSW FuelCheck pump prices across 631 Sydney stations, replayed as weekly van fills under four buying rules.
Executive summary
Filling at the cheapest station in the postcode saves 5.0c a litre on diesel against the usual stop; timing the fill across three days adds +0.4c.
Situation
Drivers fill at the same station each week, and a fuel card often ties the business to one brand. Owners hear that timing the Sydney price cycle saves money.
Approach
Monday fills replayed at every Sydney station on a year of NSW FuelCheck prices, 170 stations for diesel, under four buying rules, with the timing rule tuned on earlier months and tested once on April to October 2026.
Result
Station choice saves 5.0c a litre on diesel and 5.4c on unleaded. Timing adds almost nothing. A brand-locked card needs to be worth 5c to 7c a litre to break even.
The problem
A trades business with a few utes buys fuel wherever the driver happens to be. Fuel cards give a fixed discount of a few cents a litre, but the ACCC’s work on price cycles shows the gap between stations and between days in a cycle is often larger than that discount. The owner sees the total on the card statement and has no way to tell whether it was a good week.
I measured how much a fleet saves by buying at the cheapest station near each driver’s first job, against the city median, and whether the day of the cycle or the station matters more.
- Team
- Owner or office manager, 4 to 25 vehicles
- Scale
- Roughly 70 litres a week per vehicle
- Systems
- ServiceM8, simPRO or Tradify for jobs; a fuel card; Xero for the bills
- Measure
- Cents a litre paid against the Sydney median; driver minutes per fill
What I built
A morning job reads the NSW FuelCheck prices for every station near each driver’s first job and sends one line to the driver’s phone: the cheapest station within the postcode and its price. The office sees a weekly report from the fuel card and Xero bills: litres, cents a litre against the Sydney median, and the stations used.
Results
I rebuilt the price at 7am every day for every Sydney station from the FuelCheck change log, and replayed a Monday fill at each station as if it were a van’s usual stop: 631 stations for unleaded and 170 for diesel. The timing rule waits up to two days when the price is above its recent low and not yet rising; its thresholds were chosen on September 2025 to March 2026 and tested once on April to October 2026.
| Fuel | Monday fills tested | Stations | Usual station price | Saved: cheapest local | Saved: timing rule added | Saved: perfect timing added |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diesel | 4,989 | 170 | 240.4c | 5.0c | +0.4c | +1.7c |
| Unleaded 91 | 18,781 | 631 | 197.6c | 5.4c | -0.8c | +1.3c |
The station is the decision that matters. In a tenth of fills the cheapest local station was more than 15c a litre below the usual one on diesel. Timing barely moves the bill, and on unleaded the rule lost money in the test months: thresholds that worked on the earlier months did not carry over. I would not ask drivers to chase the cycle.
On diesel, the cheapest BP station in a postcode averaged 7.0c above the cheapest station of any brand, Ampol 5.9c and Shell 4.7c. A card has to be worth about 5c to 7c a litre at those brands to break even with filling at the cheapest station; a 4c card still loses money.
Data and method
- Data
- NSW FuelCheck price history, August 2025 to October 2026, published by NSW Government Fair Trading on Data.NSW under CC BY-SA 4.0
- Scope
- Sydney metropolitan postcodes, unleaded 91 and diesel; stations with a valid price on at least 80% of days
- Price
- Price in effect at 7am from the change log; prices not updated for 30 days treated as missing
- Policies
- Usual station on Monday; cheapest station in the same postcode on Monday; the timing rule over Monday to Wednesday; perfect timing over the same window
- Split
- Rule thresholds chosen on fills to March 2026; tested once on 30 later weeks
Limitations
- Postcode is a rough stand-in for distance. In use the check limits stations to a few minutes from the route, which the FuelCheck API’s coordinates allow.
- Prices are published prices; card discounts and member pricing are applied per business.
- The test covers seven months, and the unleaded cycle changes shape over time; a timing rule would need refitting as it does.
- Driver time matters: a detour of more than a few minutes costs more than a few cents a litre on 70 litres.
How I would take it live
- Export three months of fuel-card transactions and the vans’ first-job addresses from ServiceM8 or simPRO
- Measure cents a litre against the Sydney median for each driver
- Send the morning message for six weeks to half the drivers
- Compare cents a litre and decide on the fuel card from the brand premium in the vans’ own postcodes