Manaz Afzal

Property Management · Rent reviews

Rent reviews from the rents actually agreed nearby

An evidence pack for every lease reaching its annual review, built from New South Wales bond lodgements and tested on the rents new leases achieved.

9.7%median gap to the rent achieved, against 16.5% for a postcode median
+0.2%bias, against -1.4% for the latest published quarter
5.0%typical increase the evidence supported at the first anniversary

The problem

Every residential lease on a rent roll comes up for review once a year. In New South Wales the rent can rise once in any 12 months, with at least 60 days’ written notice stating the new rent and the date it starts; in Victoria the notice period is 90 days from 25 November 2025, and the notice has to show how the new rent was worked out. A renter who thinks the increase is excessive can apply to NCAT, or ask Consumer Affairs Victoria for a rent assessment, and both look first at what comparable properties are leasing for.

In most agencies the property manager prepares each review by hand: a search of leased listings on realestate.com.au and Domain, a look at the quarterly Rent and Sales Report, and a recommendation emailed to the owner. On a portfolio of 250 managements that is about five reviews a week, done between inspections and maintenance, so the evidence is often thin and the increase ends up as a round number or a flat percentage across the roll.

I built a weekly evidence pack for each lease approaching its anniversary, from the rents actually agreed on new leases nearby, and tested how close it lands to the rent a property would achieve on the date the increase takes effect.

Team
Property managers and the head of property management; the owner approves each increase
Systems
PropertyMe, Property Tree or Console Cloud for leases and owner contacts; realestate.com.au and Domain for listings
Decision
The proposed rent and start date for each lease reaching its anniversary
Measure
Gap between the proposed rent and the rent comparable new leases achieve; increases challenged or withdrawn

What I built

Each Monday a job reads the lease end and review dates from the property management system and picks the leases whose increase could take effect in about 75 days, which leaves 60 days for the notice and two weeks for the owner to decide. For each property it pulls every bond lodged for a new lease in the previous 13 weeks with the same postcode, dwelling type and bedroom count. Where there are fewer than eight, the estimate leans on the surrounding postal district, so a quiet postcode still gets a figure without being driven by two or three leases.

The pack gives the property manager a market estimate, the middle half of comparable rents, the number of leases behind it and how far rents have moved since the current lease started. It drafts the owner’s approval email and, once approved, the increase notice with the new rent, the start date and the basis for it, ready to send from the property management system.

Lease datesReviews due in75 days, from PropertyMeComparablesNew bonds, same postcode,type and bedroomsEvidence packEstimate, middle half,leases behind itOwner approvalRecommendationemailed to the ownerNoticeNew rent, start dateand basis
The property manager still sets the rent after the last inspection; the pack gives the evidence behind it.
$600$650$700$750$800Mar 25Sep 25Mar 26Sep 26Median weekly rent, new leasesMonth the bond was lodged
One cell of the evidence: two-bedroom units in Parramatta. Rents rose through the first half of 2026 and eased from August, which a review written from a six-month-old report would miss. Data: NSW Fair Trading rental bond lodgements, CC BY 4.0, © State of New South Wales

Results

I tested the pack on 71,990 new leases that started between August and October 2026, building each estimate only from bonds lodged at least 75 days before the lease began, as a review notice would have to be. Two shortcuts were tested on the same leases: the median for the whole postcode, and the median for the same postcode, dwelling type and bedrooms from the latest quarter that would have been published by then.

Postcode-wide medianall dwellings in the postcode16.5%Latest published quartersame postcode, type and bedrooms10.0%Evidence packlast 13 weeks of new leases9.7%
Half of new leases landed within 9.7% of the evidence-pack estimate. A postcode-wide median misses by 16.5% because it mixes studios with four-bedroom houses.
Postcode-wide median33.4%Latest published quarter51.0%Evidence pack51.3%
51.3% of leases were within 10% of the pack’s estimate, against 33.4% for the postcode median.

Against the published quarter the pack is close on accuracy, 9.7% against 10.0%, but the published figure runs 1.4% below what properties were leasing for, because it is older by the time a notice goes out; the pack is within 0.2%. On a $700 a week rent that is about $10 a week under the market on each review written from the report. The middle-half range held 49.9% of actual rents, as a range of that kind should, with a typical width of 18% of the rent.

DwellingNew leases testedEvidence pack: median gapPublished quarter: median gapWithin 10%: packAverage bias: packAverage bias: published quarter
Units and flats36,54010.6%10.8%47.7%+1.1%-0.1%
Houses30,7918.7%9.0%55.2%-0.2%-2.2%
Townhouses and terraces3,4948.2%8.8%58.4%-0.1%-2.2%

Where fewer than five comparable leases were lodged, 8.6% of cases, the median gap widens to 13.0% against 9.1% for well-evidenced properties, and the pack flags those reviews for a manual search of current listings.

What the evidence said at review time

To see what the pack would have recommended, I followed 73,068 leases that started between August and October 2025 to their first anniversary and measured how far comparable rents had moved over the year.

below −12.5%0.6%−12.5% to −10.0%0.2%−10.0% to −7.5%0.4%−7.5% to −5.0%1.3%−5.0% to −2.5%1.7%−2.5% to +0.0%5.4%+0.0% to +2.5%14.6%+2.5% to +5.0%26.3%+5.0% to +7.5%23.9%+7.5% to +10.0%12.8%+10.0% to +12.5%5.7%+12.5% to +15.0%3.7%+15.0% to +17.5%1.2%+17.5% to +20.0%0.9%+20.0% to +22.5%0.5%25% or more0.9%
The typical lease had evidence for an increase of 5.0%, about $33 a week on the median rent of $700. The middle half ran from 2.6% to 7.6%.

A flat increase across the roll fits few properties. A flat 5% would have asked for at least three points more than the evidence on 20.4% of leases, the reviews most likely to be challenged, and at least three points less than the evidence on 21.5%, money the owner did not ask for. For 10.2% of leases comparable rents had not risen at all, and a hold or a small increase protects a good renter. Units moved more than houses, 5.4% against 4.6%, and 80.6% of reviews had enough leases in their own postcode to stand without the district.

Data and method

Data
NSW Fair Trading rental bond lodgements, March 2025 to October 2026, 454,165 new leases after cleaning; postcode, dwelling type, bedrooms and weekly rent; CC BY 4.0, © State of New South Wales
Test
New leases from August to October 2026, each estimated from bonds lodged in the 13 weeks ending 75 days before its month
Estimate
Median of the postcode, type and bedroom cell, blended with the surrounding postal district when fewer than eight leases (weight n / (n + 8))
Comparisons
Postcode-wide median over the same window; cell median from the latest quarter published before the notice date
Error
Median absolute percentage gap to the actual weekly rent; bias is the median signed gap
Reviews
Leases from August to October 2025 compared with comparable new leases 12 months later, blended toward the district when evidence is thin

Limitations

How I would take it live